Artificial Intelligence Has a Problem With Women & Race. Here’s How to Fix It.

by | Sep 29, 2023 | Artificial Intelligence (AI), Female Leadership

We often assume machines are neutral, but they aren’t. Joy Buolamwini’s research uncovered large gender and racial biases in AI systems sold by tech giants like IBM, Microsoft, and Amazon. Given the task of guessing the gender of a face, all companies performed substantially better on male faces than female faces.

Artificial Intelligence (AI) is a powerful tool that governs various aspects of our lives, but it’s not as neutral as we’d like to believe. Joy Buolamwini’s eye-opening article, “Artificial Intelligence Has a Problem With Gender and Racial Bias. Here’s How to Solve It”, from 2019 sheds light on the hidden problem of gender and racial bias in AI systems. As she explains, this bias has serious consequences for individuals and society at large. Let’s dive into her insights and explore how we can work together to solve this pressing issue.

The Coded Gaze: Unveiling AI’s Bias

Buolamwini’s journey into the world of AI bias began during her time as a graduate student at MIT. In a startling revelation, she found that facial analysis software struggled to detect her dark-skinned face unless she donned a white mask. This discovery highlighted a concerning issue – AI systems are often trained on images of predominantly light-skinned men, leading to a lack of accuracy for people with diverse skin tones. Buolamwini aptly named this problem the “coded gaze.”

The Exclusion Overhead: Paying the Price

Buolamwini coined another term, the “exclusion overhead,” to describe the cost of systems that don’t account for the diversity of humanity. It raises a crucial question: How much should a person change themselves to adapt to technology that increasingly governs our lives? This exclusion overhead is not just a theoretical concept; it has real-world consequences.

Gender and Racial Bias Unveiled

Buolamwini’s research didn’t stop at her own experience. She delved deeper and uncovered alarming gender and racial bias in AI systems developed by tech giants like IBM, Microsoft, and Amazon. When asked to guess the gender of a face, these systems performed significantly better on male faces than female faces. Shockingly, the error rates for darker-skinned women soared to a staggering 35%. Even iconic figures like Oprah Winfrey, Michelle Obama, and Serena Williams couldn’t escape the flawed classifications of these AI systems.

A Call to Action: The Safe Face Pledge

In response to these troubling findings, Buolamwini founded the Algorithmic Justice League and initiated the Safe Face Pledge. This pledge aims to prevent the lethal use and abuse of facial analysis and recognition technology. Already, three companies have agreed to sign it. Recent graduates, you too can join this movement to make AI safer and more inclusive.

Technology’s Dark Side: Amplifying Bias

While AI holds immense potential, it also has a dark side. It can amplify sexist hiring practices, perpetuate racist criminal justice procedures, enable predatory advertising, and spread false information. However, the silver lining is that we’re now paying attention to these issues. This awareness allows us to address them early and prevent further damage.

The Need for Broad Representation

Buolamwini emphasizes the importance of diversity in the design, development, deployment, and governance of AI. The underrepresentation of women and people of color in the tech industry, coupled with the under-sampling of these groups in AI training data, has led to technology optimized for only a fraction of the world’s population.

Shifting Toward Ethical AI

Despite the challenges, Buolamwini remains optimistic. She believes there’s still time to shift towards building ethical and inclusive AI systems that respect human dignity and rights. By reducing the exclusion overhead and involving marginalized communities in AI development and governance, we can work towards creating systems that embrace full-spectrum inclusion.

The Power of Storytelling

In this journey towards inclusive AI, Buolamwini stresses the role of storytellers who combine art and science to expose the emotional, societal, and historical dimensions of algorithmic bias. Stories have the power to shift perspectives, ignite change, and reaffirm that everyone’s experiences matter.

Conclusion: A Brighter Future for AI

In closing, Buolamwini’s article reminds us that AI, though powerful, is not infallible. It reflects the biases present in society, and it’s up to us to champion inclusive AI. Let’s work together to ensure that AI systems respect the dignity and rights of all individuals, regardless of their gender or skin color. The path to a brighter, fairer AI future starts with us.

<a href="https://www.executiveinsider.org/author/blogauthor19/" target="_self">EI Insights Blog</a>
EI Insights Blog
As co-founder of Executive Insider, Torah Bontrager brings a unique blend of entrepreneurial, nonprofit, and AI expertise to her work, focused on overcoming the challenges faced by first-generation professionals (FGPs). She architects the holistic infusion of artificial intelligence throughout the RISE curriculum's pedagogy. As co-founder of Executive Insider, May Teo is an educator, mentor, and curriculum designer dedicated to advancing the careers of First-Generation Female Professionals. She leads the development of the RISE curriculum, a multi-tiered leadership pathway that equips women to transition from survival mode to visible, impactful leadership.

Hi First Generation Female Professional!

Are You Trapped in the GAP™?

Join our community of trailblazing women

. . . where we celebrate diversity and welcome your unique perspective.

Related Posts

The Cohort-Based RISE Fellowship

Our 18-month RISE Fellowship is a four-phase journey that transitions FGPs from career survival to sustainable leadership and legacy. Through sequenced curricula in Career Ownership, Strategic Navigation, Leading with Impact, and Community Building, we provide the critical support needed at every stage of a first-generation female professional's career.

Our fellowship is not a one-time course but a sustained journey. Each tier builds upon the previous to facilitate lasting transformation.

GOAL: TRANSITION FROM GRATEFUL WORKER → CAREER CEO

Tier 1: RISE Foundation Curriculum (Career Ownership)

This 90-day tier equips FGPs with the confidence, tools, and energy strategies to claim ownership of their careers. Every module leverages AI, teaching Fellows how to use artificial intelligence for energy stewardship and to reduce invisible labor.
GOAL: TRANSITION FROM EARLY PROFESSIONAL → STRATEGIC NAVIGATOR

Tier 2: RISE Advancement Curriculum (Strategic Navigation)

This 90-day tier equips FGPs to navigate politics, gain sponsorship, and practice strategic visibility in professional arenas. Every module leverages AI, teaching Fellows how to use artificial intelligence to simulate high-stakes environments, analyze complex networks, and refine strategic communication to build confidence before real-world execution.
GOAL: TRANSITION FROM STRATEGIC NAVIGATOR → VISIBLE LEADER WHO SHAPES SYSTEMS

Tier 3: RISE Leadership & Legacy Curriculum (Leading with Impact)

This 90-day tier equips FGPs to embrace leadership roles, mentor others, and design careers with lasting impact. Every module leverages AI, teaching Fellows how to use artificial intelligence to refine their leadership voice, model sustainable practices, and prototype systemic change, validating that their impact is both profound and enduring.
GOAL: TRANSITION FROM LEADER → TRAILBLAZER & COMMUNITY BUILDER

Tier 4: RISE Trailblazer Alumni Curriculum (Community Builders)

This 90-day tier equips FGPs to serve as mentors, advocates, and ambassadors who strengthen the ecosystem for future FGPs. Every module leverages AI, teaching Fellows how to use artificial intelligence to scale their mentorship, amplify their advocacy, and safeguard their sustainability, positioning their legacy to create a lasting cycle of empowerment for the next generations.

Fully-Funded by Our Generous Partners

Thanks to the support of our grantmakers and sponsors, the RISE Fellowship is offered at no cost to all selected FGPs, facilitating equitable access and opportunity for every Fellow.

Program Impact

The RISE Fellowship is designed to deliver a measurable return on investment, transforming communities and individual careers and strengthening the talent pipeline with first-generation women (FGPs). Our layered evaluation strategy tracks both quantitative and qualitative outcomes, so we capture the full depth of each Fellow's journey through the 18-month pathway.

Cross-Tier Impact & Economic Mobility Metrics

Within one year of completing their Fellowship, we project that our Fellows will achieve tangible career milestones that directly contribute to closing the wage and opportunity gap:

Promotion & Raise Rate: Over 50% of Fellows will report a promotion, significant raise, or transition to a more advanced role.

Network Growth: 70% will report a measurable strengthening of their professional support network.

Confidence in Advocacy: 85% will report increased confidence in negotiating salary, promotions, and scope of work.